This leads to Paddy capturing Louise and Agnes and holding them at gunpoint.
Louise is responsible for injuring Paddy further and killing Mike and Ciara.
However, Ant cannot do the same.

The decision to have Ben not kill Paddy and Ant do it is crucial.
How Many Families Did Paddy & Ciara Kill In The Past?
The two major clues come with Paddy’s watch collection and the photo album that Ant shows Agnes.

Speak No Evil is a 2024 horror-thriller film by writer-director James Watkins. A remake of the 2022 movie Speak No Evil follows a family who head to the country for a much-needed vacation - but the situation quickly deteriorates, thrusting them into a horrific nightmare.
Ant flips through eight different pictures of Paddy and Ciara with different kids and parents.
Meanwhile, Paddy has nine watches, which are essentially his trophies from previous murders.
This indicates thatPaddy and Ciara killed eight different families, and Ben and Louise would’ve been the ninth.

Was Ciara Really The First Kid Paddy Took?
Is This True, Or Is It Another Lie?
A potentially disturbing reveal comes inSpeak No Evil’s ending regarding the truth of Ciara and Paddy’s relationship.

The movie seems to provide enough evidence to make the claim believable, though.
The 2022 Speak No Evil ending is much darker than the 2024 remake.
The new movie almost completely reverses the fates of the characters compared toShudder’sSpeak No Evilendingtoo.

They refuse to take necessary actions when the opportunities are presented to them to possibly earn safety.
And comparison is usually damning in such cases.
But Speak No Evil holds its own thanks to the decision to completely change the ending.

That’s completely the opposite of Ant’s upbringing, at least under Paddy and Ciara’s supervision.

