Perhaps no character epitomizes this balancing act better than Mellish.

For a Jewish soldier like Mellish, coming face-to-face with a symbol of this poisonous ideology is understandably affecting.

There is an obvious surface symbolism to this scene.

Article image

On one level,it speaks to Mellish’s Jewishnessand his personal investment in the fight against the Nazis.

For a Jewish soldier like Mellish, coming face-to-face with a symbol of this poisonous ideology is understandably affecting.

This is not the only example of Mellish’s Jewishness affecting his behavior.

Saving Private Ryan -  Why Private Fish Mellish Cried When He Got The Hitler Youth Knife

Custom image by Milica Djordjevic

However, beyond this, there are several other explanations behind the deliberately enigmatic scene.

Again, this interpretation is supported by circumstantial evidence.

Mellish makes a joke and then reacts tearfully, indicating his emotional personality.

saving private ryan mellish adam goldberg

Horvath focuses on gathering sand from the beach a ritual he has conducted in every country he’s visited.

There are other mitigating factors that add to the emotional maelstrom.

He is also one of the few members of Miller’s team that displays multiple sides to his personality.

Tom Hanks in Saving Private Ryan.

This all plays out while Upham crouches on the stairs outside, paralyzed by fear.

Your Rating

Your comment has not been saved

Cast

Mellish smoking a cigarette Saving Private Ryan

Adam Goldberg as Mellish with a knife being pushed into his chest in Saving Private Ryan

Headshot Of Tom Sizemore

Headshot Of Adam Goldberg In The The Devil Los Angeles Premiere

Movies

Saving Private Ryan