In other words, the quintessential romantasy shadow daddy is an impossibility.

It’s fine to disagree with my ranking - after all, that’s the fun of a list!

  • but c’mon be respectful if commenting on this article.

Book covers of the ACOTAR series

Kingfisher from theFae & Alchemyseries is no exception.

There’s just not enoughtherethere yet, which is why he comes in last place on the list.

Of course, his hateful nature isn’t entirely his fault, what with him being cursed and all.

Throne of Glass, A Court of Thorns and Roses, and Crescent City book covers

7Orion “Hunt” Athalar

Crescent City Series

Sarah J.

Still, we love the trope for a reason, and Hunt is a great example of the archetype.

Instead, he has the power of empathy, which allows him to feel emotions in others.

Ben Barnes as General Kirigan in Shadow & Bone

For that reason, I can’t place him higher on the list.

He’s also the king of sass, and we do love a sassy, intellectual man.

Instead, he respects her decision and remains her loyal friend.

Ben Barnes as the Darkling in Netflix’s Shadow & Bone on a background of Quicksilver & The Songbird & the Heart of Stone covers

Custom image by Simone Ashmoore

Basically, protect Asar at all costs.

He’s a devoted lover and friend, and he has one of the biggest hearts in romantasy.

1Aleksander Morozova/The Darkling

The Grishaverse Series

Is the Darkling a hero?

The cover of Quicksilver by Callie Hart with a turquoise background with black branches on the sides

Custom Image by Yeider Chacon

Does he get the girl in the end?

No, he doesn’t.

He’s not a hero and the books don’t pretend that he is.

Timothée Chalamet and Charles Melton on either side of the Quicksilver book

He’s a villain, through and through.

Still, Aleksander Morozova, a.k.a.

the Darkling, is the literal shadow daddy to end all shadow daddies.

Kingdom of the Wicked’s book cover in a box set of the series.

He is the quintessential cautionary tale of how absolute power corrupts absolutely.

He’s the “I can fix him” meme personified, and we love him for it.

Hearing him drop the famous line “Fine.

Imagery from The Empyrean Series

Custom image by Yeider Chacon

Make me your villain.”

from the books was so worth the wait.

The covers for all three Crescent City books against a red, green, and yellow background

Custom Image by Sam MacLennan

A custom image of ACOTAR, ACOWAR, and ACOSF with a smokey background.

The book cover of the second novel in the Blood and Ash series, A Kingdom of Flesh and Fire.

Throne of Glass and Crown of Midnight book covers

Custom image by Yailin Chacon

A Court of Thorns and Roses, A Court of Mist and Fury, and A Court of Silver Flames Book Covers

Custom image by Yailin Chacon

The Songbird & the Heart of Stone featuring a white background, the title in brown, and a golden pen

The cover of A Court of Thorns & Roses with all four sequels behind it and a blue background that’s cracked like glass

Custom Image by Ana Nieves