His daughter, Ishana Shyamalan, also made her directorial debut withThe Watchers, adapting A.M.

Shine’s fantasy book.

The dual 2024 releases set up a showdown for the Shyamalan family.

26rrxmtsiz6p4d9hcik217hekil.jpg

AlthoughThe WatchersandTrapwere released months apart, the Shyamalan family link between them made comparisons inevitable.

And the response makes M. Night Shyamalan andTrapthe winner over Ishana andThe Watchers.

M. Night Shyamalan’s Trap and Ishana Night Shyamalan’s The Watchers both utilize the same common horror/thriller trope.

M. Night Shyamalan in front of The Watchers and Trap posters

Custom Image by Ana Nieves

Here’s our breakdown.

This has been done after it made $15.4 million in its opening weekend domestically.

It’s made $28.6 million domestically overall and added $16.7 million internationally.

Dakota Fanning in The Watchers and Josh Hartnett in Trap

In comparison,The Watchersonly made $32.9 million at the box officeoverall.

The movie had a disappointing opening weekend at only $7 million domestically.

But,Traphas still already managed to surpassThe Watchers' box office total worldwide in less than two weeks.

Headshot Of Josh Hartnett In The 77th British Academy Film Awards (BAFTAs)

It appears thatTrapis also on track to be a box office success, whereasThe Watcherswas not.

The former received stronger reviews from critics and audiences alike compared to the latter.

Although critics were still mixed overall,Trapreceived a 55% score on the Tomatometer.

Headshot Of Hayley Mills

General audiences were a bit more positive, with it receiving a 65% Audience Score from verified ratings.

M. Night Shyamalan’s Trap leaves audiences with mysteries and room to theorize about the film’s events.

Here’s what we’re still wondering.

Headshot Of Marnie McPhail

Reviews were generally a bit harsher onThe Watchers.

The experience gained by writing and directing her first feature film is invaluable.

It’s also worth noting thatSaleka Shyamalan made her acting debutamongTrap’s castand showcased her talent.

Cast Placeholder Image

M. Night has to be proud of his family at the very least.

Cooper (Josh Hartnett) with a suspicious expression in Trap

Image via Warner Bros.

Headshot oF Dakota Fanning

Josh Hartnett as Cooper in Trap

Shyamalan V Shyamalan Will Be Summer 2024s Best Box Office Battle

Custom Image by Simone Ashmoore

Movies

Trap

The Watchers