There are a few elements that are vital whencasting the new Elle.

First and foremost, it seems important that the actress somewhat resembles the character, and Witherspoon herself.

However, it may also be beneficial to choose an actress that has something to prove.

Reese Witherspoon as Elle Woods looking excited in a store in Legally Blonde

Either way, the following ten actors could bring something different to the role.

Carpenter is an interesting case because she is at a unique point in her career.

For the most part, McKenzie has played roles that are quite different from Elle.

Collage of Kiernan Shipka in Mad Men, Chilling Adventures of Sabrina and Totally Killer

For the most part, McKenzie has played roles that are quite different from Elle.

Similarly, inLast Night in Soho,she takes on a more quiet and vulnerable role.

One such project isYellowjackets,and a perfect pick fromtheYellowjacketscastis Sophie Nelisse.

Legally Blonde Elle Woods Movie and Musical

InYellowjackets,Nelisse is fierce and tough, lacking any of the teenage frivolity that is inherent in Elle.

If anything, herYellowjacketscounterpart, Jackie, is a better fit.

Just looking at her, Nelisse could definitely portray a bedazzled popular girl if she needed to.

Elle Woods in court in Legally Blonde

7Angourie Rice

A High School Professional

One last unexpected pick for Elle is Angourie Rice.

Not only that, but she can transform these characters' personalities in interesting ways.

As Cady, Rice is awkward and adorable.

Legally Blonde (2001)

InHonor Society,she is ambitious and slightly devious.

In this way,Rice could certainly embody Elle’s determination while also channeling her popular girl attitude.

Plus,Ellecould truly put Rice’s name on the map.

Headshot Of Reese Witherspoon In The 49th AFI Life Achievement Award

The thing that makesNewton such a great candidate is that she’s completely likable.

Through her rough exterior, she has a heart of gold and a perfect sense of relatability.

This is ideal for Elle who, despite all her fashion and energy, is just another young woman.

Headshot Of Victor Garber

Newton could definitely bring the humanity to Elle Woods.

School Spiritsseason 2 premieres on February 3, 2025.

Now,Ellecould be a new version of that, with more maturity and depth.

Though not an actual high schooler, she still evokes a sense of youth.

In this way, Donnelly deserves another chance to show that she can go beyondDisney original movies.

Donnelly would also be a strong contender because she isn’t super well known.

Donnelly is another actress who has the perfect look for Elle Woodsand the resume to prove it.

Ultimately, balancing on this line is vital for whoever plays Elle.

Your Rating

Your comment has not been saved

Cast