His potential return also signals that the studio would rather play things safe than get experimental again.

Scott’s talent for visuals and their ambitious scope notwithstanding, both entries were let down by sloppy storytelling.

Scott’sCovenantwasPrometheus 2with someAlienelements bolted on, when the series needed something entirely new.

Alien Romulus Poster Showing a Facehugger Attacking A Human

That’s a fairly reductive description - but it’s not inaccurate either.

The reason they work is the talented filmmakers behind them, from the writers to the actors and craftspeople.

This made it feel more dangerous than the average sequel and even set it apart from Scott’s original.

Andy from Alien: Romulus and The Deacon creature from Prometheus

Custom image by Ana Nieves

There’s no shortage of worthwhile candidates in the field either, just looking at 2024’s horror line-up.

Oz Perkins’Longlegsbrought a fairytale edge to the jaded serial killer genre, resulting in a word-of-mouth hit.

Each one would do something totally different withAlien, which would be more exciting than aRomulus 2.

The Offspring from Alien: Romulus (2024) next to Cailee Spaeny as Rain and a blurred poster for the film

Custom image by Debanjana Chowdhury

Rain (Cailee Spaeny) in Alien Romulus and an Engineer in a chair in Prometheus

Alien Romulus Fede Alvarez in front of a xenomorph with blood

Custom image by Debanjana Chowdhury

Headshot Of Cailee Spaeny In The Los Angeles Special Screening Of A24’s ‘Civil War’

Headshot Of David Jonsson

Movies

Alien: Romulus

Alien